Top Hotels in Montauk for Unforgettable Stays

We checked thousands of reviews on and to find the best hotels for your stay
Go to Hotel List View map

Alardo Riojas

Updated: 28 February 2024 · 3 min

Nestled at the eastern tip of Long Island, Montauk is a gem that offers a blend of serene beaches, rugged natural beauty, and a laid-back lifestyle that captivates every visitor. This picturesque destination is not only famous for its stunning landscapes and rich history but is also home to a diverse range of accommodations that cater to every taste and budget. Discovering the right hotel in Montauk can significantly enhance your trip, making it an unforgettable experience steeped in comfort and local charm.

The array of hotels in Montauk is as varied as the town's own landscape, ranging from luxurious beachfront properties to cozy, budget-friendly inns. Each offers a unique vantage point to immerse yourself in the tranquil beauty of Montauk, allowing you to wake up to the soothing sounds of the ocean or the serene views of the lush countryside. Selecting the perfect stay involves considering what you want out of your Montauk adventure, whether it's a romantic getaway, a family vacation, or a solo retreat to reconnect with nature.

With an insider’s insight into the best hotels in Montauk this article aims to guide you through the top accommodations that promise an idyllic stay. From amenities and ambiance to proximity to local attractions, we'll delve into what makes each hotel a standout. Prepare to explore Montauk like never before, with a stay that not only meets your needs but also exceeds your expectations, ensuring your time in this coastal haven is as comfortable and captivating as the town itself.
Show more + Show less -

Our Top 5

(Sorted by rating & number of reviews)

1. Montauk Manor Hotel
2. The Montauk Beach House
3. Montauk Blue Hotel
4. Gurney'S Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa
5. Beachcomber Resort At Montauk

Luxury Hotels in Montauk, NY

Check Availability

Montauk
Dec 06, 2025 - Dec 07, 2025

Montauk Manor Hotel

8.7

Good

(1825 Reviews)

+ 56 photos
Steeped in history, Montauk Manor offers an opulent step back in time with its Tudor-style architecture and grandeur that echoes the splendor of a bygone era. Nestled atop a hill, it provides panoramic views of Montauk's natural beauty, making it a picturesque escape from the everyday. The Manor's accommodations range from elegant studios to spacious suites, all adorned with period furnishings and modern amenities, ensuring a comfortable yet luxurious stay. Guests can enjoy a variety of on-site activities, including tennis courts, an indoor and outdoor pool, and a state-of-the-art fitness center. The in-house restaurant serves exquisite dishes crafted from local ingredients, adding to the luxurious experience. Montauk Manor is not just a hotel but a destination that offers a unique blend of historical elegance and contemporary luxury in Montauk .
Address: 236 Edgemere Street
Rating: Good 8.7 (1825 Reviews)
Rooms: 96
Price: From 174$

The Montauk Beach House

8.3

Good

(69 Reviews)

+ 111 photos
The Montauk Beach House strikes a perfect balance between luxury and the laid-back beach lifestyle intrinsic to Montauk in the very heart of Montauk, just a short walk from the beach, this boutique hotel embodies the spirit of a beach retreat with its stylishly designed rooms, outdoor pools, and lively poolside events. Guests can enjoy the sun on the hotel's private section of the beach, complete with loungers and umbrellas for a relaxing day by the ocean. The rooms, with their chic decor and comfortable furnishings, provide a tranquil sanctuary after a day in the sun. The on-site café and bar serve up refreshing cocktails and delicious bites, capturing the essence of beachfront dining. The Montauk Beach House is the epitome of a beachfront hotel, offering an experience that combines the comfort of a luxury stay with the beauty and excitement of Montauk's coastal lifestyle.
Address: 55 South Elmwood Avenue
Rating: Good 8.3 (69 Reviews)
Rooms: 35
Price: From 449$

Family-Friendly Hotels in Montauk, NY

Families planning a getaway to Montauk will find a selection of hotels designed to cater to the needs of both adults and children. These family-friendly hotels in Montauk not only offer comfortable and spacious accommodations but also feature a variety of amenities and activities meant to entertain guests of all ages. From kid-friendly pools and play areas to family-oriented dining and programming, each hotel aims to create an environment where families can connect and create lasting memories. Situated close to Montauk's top attractions, these hotels serve as the perfect base for exploring all that the area has to offer. Whether you're looking to spend your days on the beach, discover local wildlife, or simply relax and enjoy quality time together, these family-friendly accommodations promise a delightful and stress-free stay.

Montauk Blue Hotel

8.6

Good

(1217 Reviews)

+ 34 photos
Located directly on the shoreline, Montauk Blue Hotel offers families an unforgettable beachfront stay where the ocean is just steps away. With a variety of room configurations, including spacious suites with kitchenettes, the hotel caters to families of all sizes, ensuring a comfortable and convenient stay. The indoor heated pool is a favorite among children, allowing for fun and relaxation regardless of the weather. The hotel's prime location means easy access to Montauk's family-friendly attractions, such as the Montauk Point Lighthouse and state parks. On-site barbecue facilities provide the perfect opportunity for a family cookout, offering a taste of home amidst the beauty of Montauk. Montauk Blue Hotel is dedicated to making family vacations as enjoyable and hassle-free as possible, with a warm and welcoming atmosphere that feels like a home away from home.
Address: 108 South Emerson Avenue
Rating: Good 8.6 (1217 Reviews)
Rooms: 30
Price: From 215$

Gurney'S Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa

8.0

Good

(196 Reviews)

+ 204 photos
Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa is a beacon of luxury, boasting a pristine oceanfront location that offers guests direct access to one of Montauk's finest beaches. With its sophisticated ambiance, the resort is a haven for those seeking relaxation and rejuvenation. The Seawater Spa, featuring a sea-fed saltwater pool, is unique in New York and offers a range of treatments that harness the healing properties of the ocean. Each guest room and suite is designed with an elegant, nautical theme, providing a tranquil retreat with breathtaking views of the Atlantic. Dining at Gurney's is a culinary journey, with several restaurants offering everything from fresh seafood to gourmet Italian cuisine. This resort is a luxurious sanctuary where every moment is tailored to ensure guests experience the epitome of luxury in Montauk .
Address: 290 Old Montauk Highway
Rating: Good 8.0 (196 Reviews)
Rooms: 158
Price: From 372$

Beachfront Hotels in Montauk, NY

For those dreaming of waking up to the sound of the waves and the scent of the ocean breeze, Montauk offers a selection of beachfront hotels that promise just that. These accommodations provide direct access to Montauk's stunning beaches, combining the comfort of a hotel stay with the allure of the seaside. Beyond just a room with a view, these beachfront hotels in Montauk offer an immersive experience, allowing guests to effortlessly transition from their cozy beds to the sandy shores. With amenities designed to enhance your beach getaway, including on-site dining with ocean views, water sports rentals, and beach loungers and umbrellas, each hotel ensures a memorable and hassle-free beach vacation. Whether you're seeking a romantic retreat or a solo adventure, these beachfront properties cater to every preference, making your Montauk stay an exquisite encounter with the ocean.

Beachcomber Resort At Montauk

8.5

Good

(161 Reviews)

+ 45 photos
Beachcomber Resort at Montauk is a haven for families looking for a blend of comfort and adventure in Montauk close to the beach and within short driving distance to Montauk's charming town center, the resort features spacious accommodations equipped with full kitchens, making family stays a breeze. The resort's outdoor pool, tennis court, and easy beach access offer endless entertainment for kids and adults alike. Beachcomber Resort prioritizes guest comfort and convenience, with a dedicated staff ready to recommend family-friendly activities and dining options in Montauk. The resort's tranquil setting and comprehensive amenities provide a perfect backdrop for families to unwind and spend quality time together. For families seeking a relaxing yet engaging vacation in Montauk at Montauk presents an ideal choice.
Address: 727 Old Montauk
Rating: Good 8.5 (161 Reviews)
Rooms: 79
Price: From 215$

Boutique Hotels in Montauk, NY

Boutique hotels in Montauk offer a unique and personalized lodging experience, distinguishing themselves with their attention to detail, distinctive style, and intimate atmosphere. These selections are perfect for travelers seeking accommodations with character, blending exceptional service with a local touch. Each boutique hotel in Montauk reflects the town's vibrant personality, with designs and themes that draw inspiration from the local culture, history, and natural surroundings. Guests can expect a warm welcome and a stay filled with unexpected delights, from individually decorated rooms to gourmet dining options. Situated in picturesque locations, these boutique hotels provide a tranquil yet convenient base for exploring Montauk's charms. For those yearning for a stay that's out of the ordinary, these boutique hotels promise an unforgettable escape in Montauk .