Captivating Unique New York Hotels

We checked thousands of reviews on and to find the best hotels for your stay
Go to Hotel List View map

Alardo Riojas

Updated: 03 February 2024 · 5 min

When it comes to accommodations, the city offers a plethora of options, ranging from luxurious hotels to charming boutique stays. However, for those seeking a truly memorable experience, the unique New York hotels are the hidden gems waiting to be discovered. These hotels offer a blend of distinctive architecture, personalized service, and unparalleled character, making them stand out in a city already known for its grandeur.

Imagine stepping into a hotel that was once a historic landmark or a converted warehouse, each with its own story to tell. From converted Victorian brownstones in Brooklyn to art-inspired boutique hotels in Manhattan's lively neighborhoods, unique New York hotels provide an authentic glimpse into the city's rich history and vibrant creativity. Whether it's the sleek minimalist design of a modernist hotel in Chelsea or the cozy elegance of a hidden gem in the Upper East Side, each property offers an escape from the cookie-cutter accommodations found elsewhere.

Not only do these unique New York hotels provide a visually stunning stay, but they also offer an array of amenities and services that cater to the discerning traveler. Many of these properties boast rooftop bars with panoramic views of the city skyline, serene spa retreats for a rejuvenating experience, and on-site restaurants serving innovative cuisine curated by renowned chefs. The staff is often praised for their exceptional attention to detail, ensuring that every guest feels like a VIP. If you're looking to immerse yourself in the true essence of New York City, these unique hotels are your ticket to an unforgettable stay that goes beyond the ordinary.
Show more + Show less -

Our Top 10

(Sorted by rating & number of reviews)

1. Gramercy Park Hotel
2. The Greenwich Hotel
3. The Kimberly Hotel
4. The Beekman, A Thompson Hotel, By Hyatt
5. The William Vale Hotel
6. The New York Edition
7. The High Line Hotel
8. 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge
9. The Assemblage John Street Hotel
10. The Marlton Hotel

Unique New York Hotels for Art Enthusiasts

Check Availability

New York
Nov 29, 2025 - Nov 30, 2025

Gramercy Park Hotel

8.0

Good

(231 Reviews)

+ 137 photos
Situated near Manhattan's iconic Gramercy Park, The Gramercy Park Hotel boasts a rich artistic history and a captivating collection of contemporary art. The hotel's opulent design, created by renowned artist Julian Schnabel, features vibrant colors, luxurious textiles, and custom-made furniture. Every corner of this hotel doubles as an art gallery, adorned with original pieces by celebrated artists. Guests can soak up the artistic atmosphere while enjoying exclusive access to the private Gramercy Park, a lush oasis in the very heart of the city.
Address: 2 Lexington Avenue
Rating: Good 8.0 (231 Reviews)
Rooms: 190
Price: From 387$

The Greenwich Hotel

9.1

Good

(90 Reviews)

+ 65 photos
Tucked away in the trendy Tribeca neighborhood, The Greenwich Hotel offers an intimate and gastronomic experience unlike any other. The hotel's renowned restaurant, Locanda Verde, serves rustic Italian cuisine crafted using locally sourced ingredients. Guests can unwind at the Shibui Spa, which boasts a traditional Japanese bathhouse and offers exclusive treatments inspired by ancient healing techniques. The Greenwich Hotel's commitment to sustainability and the local community make it an ideal choice for culinary explorers seeking a unique and immersive stay.
Address: 377 Greenwich Street
Rating: Good 9.1 (90 Reviews)
Rooms: 59
Price: From 925$

Unique New York Hotels for History Buffs

Embark on a journey back in time by staying at these unique New York hotels that pay homage to the city's rich history. From converted landmarks to historical brownstones, these accommodations offer a glimpse into New York's past while providing modern comfort and unique experiences for history enthusiasts. Indulge in the nostalgia and charm of these carefully selected hotels that transport you to a bygone era.

The Kimberly Hotel

+ 43 photos
Located in Midtown East, The Kimberly Hotel offers a unique rooftop retreat for nature enthusiasts. The hotel's private rooftop terrace, Upstairs at the Kimberly, provides a serene escape with panoramic views of the cityscape. Guests can lounge by the rooftop pool, surrounded by lush plants and cozy seating areas, while enjoying a refreshing cocktail. The Kimberly Hotel seamlessly combines urban sophistication with a touch of natural tranquility, providing a serene haven for nature lovers amidst the city's excitement.
Address: 145 East 50Th Street
Rooms: 194
Price: From 399$

The Beekman, A Thompson Hotel, By Hyatt

8.6

Good

(326 Reviews)

+ 129 photos
Housed in a stunning Victorian-era building, The Beekman exudes old-world elegance with its soaring atrium and architectural details. This iconic hotel seamlessly blends history with contemporary luxury, featuring restored elements alongside stylish furnishings. Guests can explore the hotel's Book Cellar, a hidden library hosting literary events, or savor delicious cuisine at Augustine, a restaurant inspired by the classic brasseries of Paris. The Beekman's rich history and sophisticated ambiance make it a haven for history buffs seeking a unique and memorable stay.
Address: 123 Nassau Street
Rating: Good 8.6 (326 Reviews)
Rooms: 287
Price: From 337$

Unique New York Hotels for Culinary Explorers

Embark on a gastronomic adventure by staying at these unique New York hotels that celebrate the city's vibrant culinary scene. From Michelin-starred restaurants to intimate dining experiences, these hotels offer tantalizing delights for the discerning palate. Immerse yourself in the world of flavors and indulge in unforgettable dining experiences while enjoying your stay in these handpicked hotels that cater to culinary explorers.

The William Vale Hotel

8.2

Good

(1436 Reviews)

+ 119 photos
Located in the vibrant neighborhood of Williamsburg, The William Vale combines sleek design with culinary excellence. The hotel is home to Westlight, a rooftop bar and restaurant offering panoramic views of the city skyline and delectable dishes inspired by global flavors. Guests can also indulge in a variety of culinary experiences, including private cooking classes and tastings led by acclaimed chefs. With its modern and innovative approach to cuisine, The William Vale delivers an unforgettable stay for food enthusiasts looking to explore the vibrant culinary scene of Brooklyn.
Address: 111 North 12Th Street
Rating: Good 8.2 (1436 Reviews)
Rooms: 183
Price: From 429$

The New York Edition

8.4

Good

(75 Reviews)

+ 108 photos
Housed in the iconic Metropolitan Life Clock Tower, The New York Edition seamlessly blends historic architecture with contemporary luxury. The hotel's interior, designed by renowned architect David Rockwell, exudes sophistication and elegance. Guests can marvel at the building's original Beaux-Arts details while enjoying modern amenities and impeccable service. The New York Edition's unique combination of grandeur and modernity make it an architectural gem that showcases the city's rich history while offering a luxurious stay.
Address: 5 Madison Avenue
Rating: Good 8.4 (75 Reviews)
Rooms: 271
Price: From 719$

Unique New York Hotels for Nature Lovers

Escape the bustling city and reconnect with nature by staying at these unique New York hotels for nature lovers. These accommodations offer a serene retreat amidst the urban landscape, providing a balance between tranquility and the vibrant energy of New York City. Immerse yourself in natural beauty and embrace the peaceful ambiance of these hand-picked hotels that cater to nature enthusiasts.

The High Line Hotel

8.3

Good

(196 Reviews)

+ 65 photos
Nestled in a historic red-brick building near the High Line, The High Line Hotel offers a tranquil oasis in the center of Manhattan. Surrounded by lush gardens, this boutique hotel provides a peaceful retreat from the city's hustle and bustle. Guests can relax in the hotel's picturesque courtyard or explore the nearby elevated park that spans through the iconic Chelsea neighborhood. The High Line Hotel combines natural beauty with vintage charm, immersing guests in a serene atmosphere that is perfect for nature lovers.
Address: 180 Tenth Avenue
Rating: Good 8.3 (196 Reviews)
Rooms: 60
Price: From 301$

1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge

8.4

Good

(631 Reviews)

+ 95 photos
Situated on the Brooklyn waterfront, 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge blends eco-luxury with breathtaking views of the Manhattan skyline. The hotel's design incorporates reclaimed materials, living greenery, and floor-to-ceiling windows that bring the outdoors in. Guests can enjoy the rooftop pool surrounded by lush gardens, relax in the Bamford Haybarn Spa, or take a stroll along the adjacent Brooklyn Bridge Park. 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge allows nature lovers to unwind in a serene environment while enjoying the convenience of being close to the city's attractions.
Address: 60 Furman Street
Rating: Good 8.4 (631 Reviews)
Rooms: 184
Price: From 552$

Unique New York Hotels for Music Aficionados

Immerse yourself in New York City's vibrant music scene by staying at these unique hotels that cater to music lovers. From live performances to stylish music-themed accommodations, these hotels offer an unforgettable experience for those who appreciate the power of music. Immerse yourself in the rhythm and melodies of the city through these carefully selected hotels that harmonize unique design with a love for music.

The Assemblage John Street Hotel

9.1

Good

(431 Reviews)

+ 48 photos
Located in the Financial District, The Assemblage John Street combines modern design with a focus on mindful living. This unique hotel offers various wellness spaces, including a meditation room, a yoga studio, and private offices catering to conscious co-working. Guests can participate in daily wellness classes, workshops, and community events that foster connection and personal growth. The Assemblage John Street creates an immersive environment for wellness enthusiasts to recharge and nurture their mind, body, and spirit amidst the vibrant energy of the city.
Address: 17 John Street
Rating: Good 9.1 (431 Reviews)
Rooms: 75
Price: From 594$

The Marlton Hotel

8.3

Good

(1100 Reviews)

+ 31 photos
Located in the lively heart of Greenwich Village, The Marlton Hotel seamlessly blends old-world charm with contemporary design. Once a bohemian haunt frequented by literary legends like Jack Kerouac, this boutique hotel features an art-filled lobby, showcasing rotating exhibitions by local artists. Each guest room is thoughtfully decorated with vintage accents and modern amenities, providing a cozy and artistic retreat. The Marlton Hotel's commitment to fostering creativity is evident through its artist-in-residence program and collaborations with renowned art organizations.
Address: 5 West 8Th Street
Rating: Good 8.3 (1100 Reviews)
Rooms: 112
Price: From 259$

Unique New York Hotels for Wellness Retreats

Escape the hustle and bustle of New York City and indulge in a wellness retreat at these unique hotels that prioritize relaxation and rejuvenation. From luxurious spa facilities to holistic wellness programs, these accommodations offer a serene haven for those seeking a break from the fast-paced city life. Embrace self-care and embark on a journey of well-being at these hand-picked hotels that cater to wellness enthusiasts.

Unique New York Hotels for Architecture Admirers

Discover the architectural wonders of New York City by staying at these unique hotels that showcase inspiring design and innovative structures. From historic buildings to avant-garde designs, these accommodations offer a visual feast for architecture admirers. Immerse yourself in the harmonious blend of aesthetics and functionality through these carefully selected hotels that epitomize architectural excellence.